Gaudio v Ford

What do you think?  Is this the image of a vehicle in which the driver should die? 

 

 1996 Ford F150 - subject vehicle

Do you think that motorists need air bag crash protection in a frontal collision in this low speed impact?  FORD DOES.

Did you know that a driver could be essentially decapitated if he is too close to a deploying air bag in an 11 mph frontal impact?  FORD DID.

On June 20, 2001, Andrew Gaudio was driving to his job site at about 4:15A.M.   He was driving his employer's 1996 Ford F150 pick up truck. It was dark and quiet as he drove along a rural road in Lackawaxen, Pennsylvannia.  What he did not know was that the stop sign normally located along this roadway at a T-intersection
 

 Ford F-150 at scene (side view).

 

 Ford F-150 at scene (rear view).

had been knocked down days earlier.  The physical evidence shows that the Ford F150 laid down skid marks when Andrew realized the stop sign was down - right before he entered the T-intersection.                     

Andrew was found on the seat of the truck.  The crash was so minor that even loose tools in the bed of the truck were undisturbed.

The NHTSA engineer and our consultants have concluded that Andrew suffered catastrophic injuries because the air bag deployed late.  The air bag system in this truck used what are known as "crash sensors" located in the front of the vehicle - in what is called the "crash zone".  Thus, in the typical barrier test at 14 mph, the front end will be sufficiently deformed to trigger the sensors and in turn these electrical devices send a message to cause the air bag to deploy.  The problem with this system, recognized by Ford and everyone else in the motor vehicle industry, is that if the crash speed is less than 14 mph and the impact surface is "soft" (eg., a yielding object) and there is no damage in the area where the sensors are installed, then either the air bag will not deploy or it will deploy late.  Late deployment of an air bag is extraordinarily dangerous.  But, why?  Because an air bag as designed must be deployed very quickly, which in turn requires a very powerful charge which deploys the air bag at a very high speed - between 120 mph and 200 mph.  Obviously, if a motorist is striken by an air bag deploying at over 120 mph, there is major concern for injury.  That then is why air bag designers developed what became a mantra for the timing of air bag deployment: "30 milliseconds and 5 inches".  Here is the testimony of one Ford engineer:

      Q.  Okay.  Let me ask you an issue about

            timing, air bag deployment timing.

            Based on your experience, are you

            familiar with the rule of thumb:  Five inches minus

            30 milliseconds?

      A.  Yes.

      Q.  And tell me what that means.

      A.  What you want to have basically is the

            air bag fully inflated before the dummy moves five

            inches, and that would be in a 30 miles an hour

            unbelted test.

      Q. Okay.  And that's in fact one of the

            ways that you set the parameters for the timing of

            an air bag, correct, because it takes an air bag

            about 30 milliseconds to inflate, so you want the

            fire signal to occur 30 milliseconds before the

            dummy is moved five inches, right?

      A. In a general sense, yes.

      Q. All right.  Now, if an air bag deploys

            after the dummy has moved five inches, would that

            deployment be considered late?

      A. It would depend on what kind of crash

            you're talking about.

PLAINTIFFS' CLAIMS OF LIABILITY

Andrew Gaudio died needlessly.  Air bags are suppose to provide added protection for motorists, not kill them!   The problem is quite obvious.  Ford designed the air bag system in this truck to fire under accident circumstances when an air bag was not needed.

Ford designed the 1996 F-150 truck with a sensor system that will always deploy in a 14 mph speed change and never deploy when the speed change is less than 8 mph. In between these two speeds is a "gray area" when the air bag may or may not deploy.

Ford's Knowledge and Alternative Designs

The risk of severe injury is low in low speed crashes absent bag deployment:

  • Fatality risk less than 1% at 20 MPH (Malliaris, 1985 and Viano, 1988).
  • Serious injury risk less than 11% at 20 MPH (Malliaris, 1985).
  • Serious injury risk less than 6% at 20 MPH (Viano, 1988).
  • Mercedes-Benz reported no major injury severity up to 18.6 MPH (Kallina, 1997).

The 1996 F-150 air bag systems was inadequately designed because the deployment threshold was set too low. By 1992, Ford realized that a frontal air bag system required an "intelligent diagnostic module" (Breed, SAE 1992). That system, used in Ford cars by 1996 included an occupant compartment sensor which served as a method to confirm that a specific crash acceleration was sufficient to require air bag deployment.  But, Ford did not put that system in its light trucks.  Another alternative was to raise the bias on the crash zone sensors (as GM had done in its light trucks by 1996) moving from 2.5g bias to a 6g bias, in which case the sensor would only send a deployment signal in those incidents, unlike this one, in which deployment is needed.

Ask an Attorney

Contact our lawyers using the form for a free lawsuit consultation.

- Privacy Policy
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Home   |   Attorneys   |   Cases   |   Consumer Safety   |   Vehicle Safety   |   Drug and Device Law   |   Personal Injury

Locations: 1710 Spruce Street, Philadelphia , PA 19103  |  1040 N. Kings Highway, Scottsdale, AZ 08034  | Olde Liberty Square, 4807 Jonestown Road, Suite 148, Harrisburg, PA 17109  |  (of Counsel) Clark Perdue & List & Co. LPA 471 E. Broad Street, Suite 1550, Columbus, OH 43215  |  8700 E. Vista Bonita Drive, Suite 268, Scottsdale, AZ 85255
Phone: (480) 515-4745 Fax: (856) 482-1911

Copyright © 2017 All rights reserved. Anapol Schwartz - Arizona Personal Injury Lawyers - Scottsdale, AZ Accident Injury Attorneys. Disclaimer | Copyright

AZ Injury Attorneys Disclaimer: This website is dedicated to providing public information regarding personal injury, medical malpractice, truck accident, birth injury, construction accident, paralysis, wrongful death and other legal information. None of the information on this site is intended to be formal legal advice, nor the formation of a lawyer or attorney client relationship. Please contact a AZ personal injury lawyer or Arizona injury attorney at our law firm for information regarding your particular case. This website is not intended to solicit clients outside the states of Pennsylvania, Arizona, Ohio, West Virginia and Arizona.